Tesla Model 3 and Model Y MOT: why tyres are the main failure
Tyre defects turned up on 11.2% of Tesla Model 3 MOT tests and 11.7% of Model Y tests in 2025, against 5.9% expected for cars of the same age and mileage (1.9 times and 2.0 times the rate), while brake defects were well below par. So on a used Tesla the tyres are the thing to inspect: tread, cuts, exposed cords and when they were last replaced.
Autoza’s analysis of DVSA’s MOT data for all of 2025. Last updated 18 November 2026.
- 11.2% and 11.7%of Model 3 and Model Y tests had a tyre defect, against 5.9% expected
- 0.33 and 0.36times the expected rate of brake defects (regenerative braking may be part of the reason)
- 15.5% and 15.6%initial fail rate overall, against 14.0% and 12.1% expected
Tyres: what DVSA found on Teslas
DVSA files every defect under one of 13 parts groups. Against cars of the same age and mileage, tyres are the group that stands out most on both Teslas: 11.2% of the 87,481 Model 3 tests and 11.7% of the 34,928 Model Y tests carried at least one tyre defect, where about 5.9% would be expected. A test counts once per group however many defects it has there.
| Measure | Model 3 | Model Y |
|---|---|---|
| Tests in 2025 | 87,481 | 34,928 |
| Tests with a tyre defect | 11.2%5.9% expected | 11.7%5.9% expected |
| Tests with a brake defect | 0.7%2.2% expected | 0.5%1.4% expected |
| Tests with a lamp or electrical defect | 1.8%2.7% expected | 1.5%2.2% expected |
| Initial fail rate, all ages | 15.5%14.0% expected | 15.6%12.1% expected |
| Initial fail rate at the first MOT | 15.1%17,058 tests | 16.4%29,040 tests |
“Expected” is the share for cars of the same age and mileage, nationally. Initial fail rate is DVSA’s measure (a fail, or a fail repaired at the station). For comparison, 10.9% of all cars had an initial fail at their first MOT.
The defects behind the tyre figure are not subtle ones. These are the five found most often on each model, with the rate for cars of the same age (not the same mileage) beside them:
| Defect | DVSA grade | Share of Model 3 tests | Rate for cars of the same age | Model 3 against that |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tyre tread below the 1.6mm legal minimum | Dangerous | 4.7% | 1.5% | 3.1 times |
| Tyre cords exposed | Dangerous | 3.4% | 1.0% | 3.4 times |
| Tyre cut deep enough to reach the cords | Major | 2.6% | 1.7% | 1.5 times |
| Suspension pin or bush excessively worn | Major | 1.1% | 0.3% | 4.1 times (few cases, less certain) |
| Tyre pressure monitoring system not working | Major | 1.0% | 0.4% | 2.8 times |
| Defect | DVSA grade | Share of Model Y tests | Rate for cars of the same age | Model Y against that |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tyre cut deep enough to reach the cords | Major | 5.1% | 2.0% | 2.5 times |
| Tyre cords exposed | Dangerous | 4.8% | 1.1% | 4.4 times |
| Tyre tread below the 1.6mm legal minimum | Dangerous | 2.3% | 1.2% | 2.0 times |
| Ball joint excessively worn | Major | 1.2% | 0.1% | 11 times (few cases, less certain) |
| Headlamp aim: too high | Major | 0.8% | 0.9% | about the same |
Tread below the 1.6mm legal minimum, a cut deep enough to reach the cords and cords showing through are all tyres that needed replacing. Exposed cords are graded Dangerous, which means the car should not be driven until the tyre is changed.
Why tyres? A possibility, not a finding
The MOT records what a tester found, not why. A common suggestion is that electric cars are heavy and deliver their torque instantly, which can wear tyres faster. That is a possibility. These figures cannot show it, and they do not say which tyres were fitted or how the cars were driven.
What they do show is a pattern across more than 120,000 tests: a Tesla is more likely than the average car of the same age and mileage to arrive at its MOT with a worn or damaged tyre. For a buyer that is a maintenance item, and one you can inspect before you pay.
Brakes are the good news
Brake defects were found on 0.7% of Model 3 tests and 0.5% of Model Y tests, against 2.2% and 1.4% expected for cars of the same age and mileage: 0.33 and 0.36 times the rate. Lamp and electrical defects were below par too (0.65 and 0.66 times). A likely reason for the brakes is regenerative braking, where the motor slows the car and the pads and discs do less of the work. That, too, is a possibility rather than something the data proves.
Overall: a little above par, and only young cars
Taken together, the Model 3 ran 1.5 points above cars of the same age and mileage (15.5% against 14.0%) and the Model Y 3.5 points above (15.6% against 12.1%). Tyres are above par and brakes and lamps are below it; the Model 3 was also above par on suspension (2.4% of tests against 1.4%).
These are young cars. Most Model 3 tests were at the first MOT (17,058) or at 4 to 5 years old (56,341), and most Model Y tests were first MOTs (29,040). There are too few older Teslas in the 2025 file to say how they hold up at seven or ten years, and the MOT does not test the battery or the motor.
What this means if you are buying a used Tesla
A failure rate describes the model, not the car in front of you, but it tells you where to look first:
- Check every tyre across its full width, including the inner edge you can only see with the wheel turned. The legal minimum tread is 1.6mm; look for cuts, bulges and cords showing.
- Look at the date code on each sidewall and at whether the four tyres match. Uneven wear, or a mix of brands and ages, is worth asking about.
- Ask when the tyres were last replaced, which ones, and for the invoice. Tyres changed recently are worth more than tyres that are about to need replacing.
- Read the MOT history on GOV.UK with the registration for earlier tyre advisories or fails. It is free.
- Do not rely on the MOT for the rest. It does not test the battery’s health or the car’s range, so ask for evidence of both.
For battery health, see the used EV battery health certificate guide. For what else goes wrong on the car, read the Tesla Model 3 common faults guide. See used Tesla Model 3s for sale. See used Tesla Model Ys for sale.
What these figures cannot tell you
- The MOT checks safety and emissions items, not the engine, clutch or gearbox, so this is one measure of how each car holds up rather than a full reliability verdict.
- These figures describe the model, all its versions together, not any one car. Two cars of the same model, age and mileage can be in completely different condition, so check the car in front of you.
- The analysis is observational: it shows that two groups differ, not why. Where we suggest a reason it is a possibility, not a finding. A manufacturer recall is a free fix, not a verdict on a model. In particular, the reasons suggested above for the tyre and brake figures are possibilities.
- An electric car has no exhaust, so the noise, emissions and leaks group is left out of this article: a low figure there says nothing about the car.
Frequently asked questions
Do Teslas fail the MOT more than other cars?
Why do Teslas fail their MOT on tyres?
Do Teslas have brake problems at the MOT?
What should I check on a used Tesla Model 3 or Model Y?
Does the MOT test a Tesla’s battery?
Source and method
- Source: DVSA’s MOT anonymised test results and defect data for all of 2025, published under the Open Government Licence v3.0. We use every class 4 (cars and light vans up to 3,000kg) first test in Great Britain that ended in a pass, fail or pass after rectification: 33,210,823 tests. It is the complete file, not a sample. Northern Ireland is tested separately and is not in it.
- Initial fail rate (the headline): the share of first tests that ended in a fail, or in a fail that was repaired and passed at the test station (a “pass after rectification”). This is the figure DVSA publishes; it was 27.7% across Great Britain in 2025. Outright fail rate: fails only, with a car fixed at the station counted as a pass (22.4% nationally). It is lower, and it is always labelled when used. The pass rates on our model fault guides count a car fixed at the station as a pass, so they are not directly comparable with the initial fail rates here.
- Models are grouped by make and the first word of the model that DVSA records, so “Nissan Qashqai” includes every Qashqai tested, of any generation. Age is the nearest whole year at the test; the first MOT is a test 1,020 to 1,139 days after the car was first used.
- The MOT checks safety and emissions items, not the engine, clutch or gearbox, so this is one measure of how each car holds up rather than a full reliability verdict.
- These figures describe the model, all its versions together, not any one car. Two cars of the same model, age and mileage can be in completely different condition, so check the car in front of you.
- The analysis is observational: it shows that two groups differ, not why. Where we suggest a reason it is a possibility, not a finding. A manufacturer recall is a free fix, not a verdict on a model.
- Parts groups are compared with cars of the same age and mileage; specific defects with cars of the same age. Tesla Model 3 and Model Y are separate model groups.
The method, every definition and caveat, the other tables and the CSV downloads are in our analysis of every 2025 MOT first test in Great Britain.
Cite as
Autoza analysis of DVSA MOT anonymised data, 2025 (autoza.co.uk/guides/tesla-model-3-model-y-mot-tyres)
Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Read the licence. Spotted something wrong, or named here and want to reply? Write to info@autoza.co.uk.