Skip to main content

Vauxhall Corsa vs Ford Fiesta: which fails its first MOT more often?

A Vauxhall Corsa failed its first MOT 14.3% of the time in 2025 against 9.1% for a Ford Fiesta, which is 57% more often (29,897 and 21,859 tests). Counting petrol cars only gives 13.6% and 9.0%, so it is not the electric Corsa, and by ten years old the two are level at 36.7% and 35.2%.

Autoza’s analysis of DVSA’s MOT data for all of 2025. Last updated 14 November 2026.

  • 14.3%of Vauxhall Corsas had an initial fail at the first MOT (29,897 tests)
  • 9.1%of Ford Fiestas did (21,859 tests)
  • 36.7% v 35.2%at ten years old, when the gap has nearly closed

The first MOT: 14.3% against 9.1%

The first MOT is the test at about three years old. DVSA counts it as an initial fail if the car fails, or fails and is repaired and passed at the test station. On that measure the Corsa failed 14.3% of 29,897 tests and the Fiesta 9.1% of 21,859, which is 57% more often. Counting only the cars that failed outright, with a repair at the station counted as a pass, the figures are 10.2% and 6.7%.

Both numbers are modest. About 86 in 100 Corsas and 91 in 100 Fiestas passed first time with nothing repaired at the station.

Is it the electric Corsa? Petrol cars only

DVSA files every Corsa under one model, electric ones included, and 3,800 of the 29,897 Corsas at their first MOT were electric. They failed 18.5%, so they do pull the average up a little. They do not explain the gap. Take them out and look at petrol cars alone:

First MOT initial fail rate, all fuels and petrol only
ModelAll fuelsPetrol onlyPetrol only, outright
Vauxhall Corsa14.3%29,897 tests13.6%25,740 tests9.5%
Ford Fiesta9.1%21,859 tests9.0%21,707 tests6.7%

Initial fail rate is DVSA’s measure (a fail, or a fail repaired at the station). The last column counts outright fails only.

Petrol Corsas failed 13.6% and petrol Fiestas 9.0%: the Corsa fails 51% more often, down from 57% but still a clear gap.

It is a spread across small cars, not one model

The Corsa is not the highest small car at its first MOT. The Hyundai i10 failed 16.4% of 7,783 first tests and the Hyundai i20 15.6% of 6,504, both higher than the Corsa. The table lists popular small cars from A to Z, not in order of failure, because a model’s place in a list says little about any one car.

First MOT initial fail rate, popular small cars, A to Z
ModelInitial fail rateTestsOutright fail rate
Citroen C38.1%11,7216.2%
Fiat 5009.6%10,3787.0%
Ford Fiesta9.1%21,8596.7%
Honda Jazz6.0%9,5723.6%
Hyundai i1016.4%7,78311.2%
Hyundai i2015.6%6,50410.6%
Kia Picanto11.8%9,0568.4%
MINI hatch10.2%32,6478.5%
Nissan Micra9.3%4,9316.9%
Peugeot 20812.5%14,4669.8%
Renault Clio11.9%6,8829.5%
Skoda Fabia9.6%6,4096.8%
Toyota Yaris7.7%31,3554.5%
Vauxhall Corsa14.3%29,89710.2%
Volkswagen Polo8.5%19,6496.5%

Only models with at least 1,000 first tests are shown. The Corsa and the Fiesta are in bold.

A different part is behind the Hyundai i10’s figure than the Corsa’s: a daytime running lamp not working turned up on 0.9% of i10 tests, 33 times the rate for cars of the same age, and the other common i10 defects are lamps, wipers and washer fluid. Many first-MOT fails on small cars are small, routine items.

How the gap changes with age

The difference is widest at 7 to 8 years, where the Corsa failed 29.3% against 21.3% for the Fiesta (8.0 points), and it has narrowed to 1.5 points by ten years old (36.7% and 35.2%).

Initial fail rate by age, Vauxhall Corsa and Ford Fiesta
Age at the testVauxhall CorsaFord FiestaCorsa minus Fiesta
First MOT (about 3 years)14.3%29,897 tests9.1%21,859 tests5.2 points
4 to 5 years16.5%85,880 tests13.0%78,328 tests3.5 points
7 to 8 years29.3%105,097 tests21.3%182,776 tests8.0 points
10 years36.7%84,684 tests35.2%122,392 tests1.5 points

Across all ages the two look closer than at the first MOT: 35.4% for the Corsa and 34.4% for the Fiesta, because the Fiesta was tested far more often at older ages (1,360,707 tests in all against 897,413). Against cars of the same age and mileage, both run above par: the Corsa by 7.9 points (27.5% expected) and the Fiesta by 5.2 points (29.2% expected).

What fails on each

These are the five defects DVSA found most often on each model across all ages, with the rate for cars of the same age beside them. They are not first-MOT figures, because the defect file is for every age together.

The five defects found most often on Vauxhall Corsa MOT tests
DefectDVSA gradeShare of Vauxhall Corsa testsRate for cars of the same ageVauxhall Corsa against that
Coil spring: fractured or brokenMajor6.2%2.5%2.5 times
Stop lamp: not workingMajor3.4%2.0%1.7 times
Track rod end dust cover damaged or deterioratedMajor3.2%0.4%8.1 times
Washers give too little washer fluidMajor2.6%1.4%1.8 times
Engine warning light on or not workingMajor2.5%1.0%2.6 times
The five defects found most often on Ford Fiesta MOT tests
DefectDVSA gradeShare of Ford Fiesta testsRate for cars of the same ageFord Fiesta against that
Stop lamp: not workingMajor6.2%2.1%2.9 times
Ball joint excessively wornMajor4.6%1.6%2.8 times
Position lamp: not workingMajor3.0%2.8%about the same
Track rod end: ball joint has excessive playMajor2.8%1.2%2.3 times
Tyre tread below the 1.6mm legal minimumDangerous2.4%2.3%about the same

The Corsa’s list has more to do with the suspension and steering: a broken coil spring on 6.2% of tests (2.5 times the rate for cars of the same age) and a damaged track rod end dust cover on 3.2% (8.1 times). Steering defects were found on 5.2% of Corsa tests, 2.8 times the rate for cars of the same age and mileage. The Fiesta’s is mostly lamps: a stop lamp not working on 6.2% of tests (2.9 times), though a worn ball joint (4.6%, 2.8 times) is the kind of safety item the test is there to catch.

Share of tests with a defect in each parts group, against cars of the same age and mileage
Parts groupCorsa shareCorsa against thatFiesta shareFiesta against that
Steering5.2%2.8 times3.7%1.8 times
Suspension12.5%1.4 times12.5%1.3 times
Lamps, reflectors and electrical13.6%1.3 times16.3%1.5 times
Tyres6.4%about par8.0%1.3 times
Brakes6.5%about par5.2%about par

Rates are compared with cars of the same age and mileage. “About par” is within a quarter either way.

We cannot say why the Corsa fails more at three years old. The MOT does not record how a car was used or serviced, and nothing here shows cause.

What this means if you are buying a used Corsa or Fiesta

A first-MOT figure of 14.3% for the Corsa is about 1 in 7 failing or needing a repair at the station; for the Fiesta, 9.1%, it is about 1 in 11. Neither is a reason to rule a car out, and a Fiesta is not safe by default: by ten years old they fail at the same rate, and both run above cars of their age and mileage. Use the figures to decide what to look at.

  1. Read the MOT history on GOV.UK with the registration. Look for what failed, what was repaired at the station and what is listed as an advisory.
  2. On a Corsa, look at the front springs and the steering: broken coil springs and damaged track rod end dust covers are the two to look for, and a knock over bumps is worth a mechanic’s time.
  3. On a Fiesta, switch on the lights and have someone check every one, the stop lamps first. Then check the front ball joints and track rod ends for play.
  4. Ask when the car was last serviced and what was done, and for the invoices.
  5. Compare like with like: a three-year-old and a ten-year-old are different cars, whichever badge they wear.

The full fault guides cover engines, gearboxes and the years to look at: Vauxhall Corsa common faults and Ford Fiesta common faults. See used Vauxhall Corsas for sale. See used Ford Fiestas for sale.

What these figures cannot tell you

  • The MOT checks safety and emissions items, not the engine, clutch or gearbox, so this is one measure of how each car holds up rather than a full reliability verdict.
  • These figures describe the model, all its versions together, not any one car. Two cars of the same model, age and mileage can be in completely different condition, so check the car in front of you.
  • Which Corsa. The group covers every generation tested. The three-year-old cars are a newer design than the ten-year-old ones, so the age columns compare different generations as well as different ages.
  • A failure is a part that did not meet the standard on test day, not a verdict on the owner. A recall is a free fix, not a verdict on the model.

Frequently asked questions

Do Vauxhall Corsas fail their MOT more than Ford Fiestas?
At the first MOT, yes: 14.3% of Corsas had an initial fail in 2025 against 9.1% of Fiestas, from 29,897 and 21,859 tests, which is 57% more often. By ten years old the figures are 36.7% and 35.2%, so the gap has nearly closed.
Is the Corsa’s first MOT figure caused by the electric Corsa?
No. 3,800 of the 29,897 Corsas tested were electric and they failed 18.5%, but petrol Corsas alone failed 13.6% against 9.0% for petrol Fiestas, a gap of 51%.
What fails most often on a Ford Fiesta MOT?
A stop lamp not working was found on 6.2% of Fiesta tests, 2.9 times the rate for cars of the same age, followed by a worn ball joint (4.6%), a position lamp not working, track rod end play and tyre tread below 1.6mm.
What fails most often on a Vauxhall Corsa MOT?
A broken coil spring was found on 6.2% of Corsa tests, 2.5 times the rate for cars of the same age, followed by a stop lamp not working, a damaged track rod end dust cover (3.2%, 8.1 times), washer fluid and the engine warning light.
Is a Corsa or a Fiesta better to buy used?
The MOT can only say so much. The MOT checks safety and emissions items, not the engine, clutch or gearbox, so this is one measure of how each car holds up rather than a full reliability verdict. On the MOT measure the Fiesta fails less at three years old and the two are level at ten, but both run above cars of their age and mileage. Compare the specific car, its history and its service record, and read the fault guides for each.

Source and method

  • Source: DVSA’s MOT anonymised test results and defect data for all of 2025, published under the Open Government Licence v3.0. We use every class 4 (cars and light vans up to 3,000kg) first test in Great Britain that ended in a pass, fail or pass after rectification: 33,210,823 tests. It is the complete file, not a sample. Northern Ireland is tested separately and is not in it.
  • Initial fail rate (the headline): the share of first tests that ended in a fail, or in a fail that was repaired and passed at the test station (a “pass after rectification”). This is the figure DVSA publishes; it was 27.7% across Great Britain in 2025. Outright fail rate: fails only, with a car fixed at the station counted as a pass (22.4% nationally). It is lower, and it is always labelled when used. The pass rates on our model fault guides count a car fixed at the station as a pass, so they are not directly comparable with the initial fail rates here.
  • Models are grouped by make and the first word of the model that DVSA records, so “Nissan Qashqai” includes every Qashqai tested, of any generation. Age is the nearest whole year at the test; the first MOT is a test 1,020 to 1,139 days after the car was first used.
  • The MOT checks safety and emissions items, not the engine, clutch or gearbox, so this is one measure of how each car holds up rather than a full reliability verdict.
  • These figures describe the model, all its versions together, not any one car. Two cars of the same model, age and mileage can be in completely different condition, so check the car in front of you.
  • The analysis is observational: it shows that two groups differ, not why. Where we suggest a reason it is a possibility, not a finding. A manufacturer recall is a free fix, not a verdict on a model.
  • First-MOT and age figures are initial fail rates for each model and age; defects are compared with cars of the same age, parts groups with cars of the same age and mileage. The petrol-only check uses first MOT tests only.

The method, every definition and caveat, the other tables and the CSV downloads are in our analysis of every 2025 MOT first test in Great Britain.

Cite as

Autoza analysis of DVSA MOT anonymised data, 2025 (autoza.co.uk/guides/vauxhall-corsa-vs-ford-fiesta-first-mot)

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Read the licence. Spotted something wrong, or named here and want to reply? Write to info@autoza.co.uk.